Ok. Every year since the Full
Monty, there has been an Indie movie that breaks out and becomes the
feel-good movie of the year. This year, it is Ghost World even
though it isn't what you'd call a feel-good movie. Ghost World
is based on a Comic
Book that I had never heard of, produced by Daniel Clowes who wrote
the screenplay. This movie tells the story of two young women, Enid
and Rebecca (Thora Birch and Scarlett Johansson), who are graduating from
high school where they were definitely part of the ``out" crowd.
They must now decide what to do with their lives. Rebecca is ready
to get on with her life and wants to get a job and her own apartment while
Enid is a bit depressed. The two are best friends but they grow apart
as the film goes on. They inhabit a comic book world which is maybe
not so surprising since the film is based on a comic book. This is particularly
true of the supporting characters who are very one-dimensional. In
particular, a lot of screen time is spent on an art class that Enid attends
taught by Indie-queen Illeana Douglas. It's meant to be comic relief
but it detracts from the rest of the movie. The exception to this
one-dimensionalism is Seymour (Steve Buscemi) who is a fortyish single
guy who collects old records and has been in the same dead-end job for
19 years. Enid and Rebecca run into him at a garage sale. Enid
is drawn to Seymour who has a similar cynical, depressive world-view.
The three main cast members, Birch, Johansson and Buscemi all put in strong
performances. Buscemi, of course, is already well known for his off-beat
roles (Armageddon, Con
Air, Fargo) and he gives
a very restrained performance as Seymour. Birch and Johansson are now 19
and 16 respectively but already have 20 years of movie experience between
them. Johansson is best known as the traumatized girl in The
Horse Whisperer and Birch for her Enid-like character in American
Beauty. Birch, in particular, shines in her role in Ghost
World. Johansson is good too but she doesn't have so much to
work with for her character which is underwritten. Ghost World
has received almost uniformly excellent reviews and I expect it
will show up on a lot of top ten lists at the end of the year. But
it isn't that great. In fact, if it weren't for Birch and Buscemi,
who rise above the material with their great performances, it would be
pretty pedestrian. Ghost World's director, Terry Zwigoff,
has only done two previous films, both documentaries, and it shows.
I really liked Ghost World at first but as time went on and the
plot meandered around and around, I liked it less and less.
I even got to the point where I wanted to look at my watch which is always
a bad sign. It's an Indie film so the production values don't have
to be so good but you expect the writing to be better. A similar
kind of film from last year was The
Tao of Steve which was also a little rough but that was more than made
up for by its good writing, characters and acting. It's possible
my expectations were set too high or that, as usual, I'm out of the mainstream
but then Claudia's first comment when we came out of the theatre was, ``I hated
it." I was a little more positive than that but Ghost World
is a little like High Fidelity,
which I thought was one of the most insightful films I'd ever seen
and my female friends thought,``boring!" In particular, High
Fidelity is a male viewpoint written by a man. Ghost World
is a female viewpoint also written by a man. This could be fine too
but Claudia felt it didn't ring true. I just thought it got
a bit boring. The film is strongest at the beginning where it is
telling the story of the two friends whose lives are moving in opposite
directions. And even though Buscemi gives a great performance, his
appearance in the film causes Johansson to more or less disappear and it
becomes a story about the relationship between an 18 year old woman and
a 40 year man who understand each other but can't be together. This
isn't so interesting. You should probably go see Ghost World anyway.
Even though it's not a completely successful film, you can see from the
length of this review that it is thought provoking.